C for 'Covert Disbalance in the Digital Age'

Image courtesy of wix ai generator

February half term was a opportunity for family time with a variety of entertaining and educational programs. We immersed ourselves in the movie magic of Imax cinemas, Leavesden 'Harry Potter' film studios*1 and enjoyed thought-provoking educational content via streaming. A highlight was watching 'Cosmos' by Neil deGrasse Tyson*2 which provided valuable insights into science. For history and geopolitics, we watched 'Turning Point' The bomb and The Cold War.*3

Last night we watched episode three of 'Turning Point' which discussed historical covert operations. The episode highlights the formation of the CIA and its role in cold war geopolitics, including coups, election meddling and disinformation campaigns, sometimes leading to long term instability.

This coincided with a significant shift in the digital landscape this weekend with tech giant Apple announcing that is has removed its highest level data security tool from customers in the UK after government demanded access to user data. Apple's removal of its Advanced Data Protection (ADP) tool for UK users, marks a critical juncture in the ongoing debate between national security and individual privacy.*4

Implications

The removal of Apple's Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature has several potential implications for all of us UK apple users. This decision exposes UK users to increased vulnerability to data breaches and cyber threats as our iCloud data loses end-to-end encryption protection. The weakening of encryption makes UK users more susceptible to various forms of cyberattacks.*5

There is now increased Government access; UK authorities may potentially access user data stored on iCloud with proper legal authorisation alongside corporate access. Apple itself will have the ability to access and potentially share user data when required. Research has shown that laws weakening encryption can result in significant economic harm to businesses, as it leaves them more susceptible to data interception and manipulation.*6,7

This also means we have limited privacy options; new UK users cannot enable ADP, while existing users will eventually need to disable this security feature.

To check if you have ADP on your IPhone: 1. Go to Settings 2. Tap your name at the top to open Apple ID Settings 3. Tap ICloud 4. Scroll down and look for 'Advanced Data Protection' - It should say 'enabled' if its activated.

Balancing national security and individual privacy rights

Where this causes covert disbalance is the global precedent setting. This decision can jeopardise the US-UK Privacy Shield risk allowing personal data transfers between the US and UK and influence other tech companies to make similar concessions, potentially weakening privacy protections globally.*8

The UK government continually emphasises the importance of national security while acknowledging the need for privacy safeguards. The UK government argues that these powers are necessary for national security and crime prevention. The Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Act 2024 has introduced several changes to the original IPA; however, the Act has faced legal challenges, with critics arguing that it violates privacy rights and freedom of expression.*9

Future implications of AI and Data Security

The UK is witnessing a concerning trend: a reduction in data encryption standards coupled with an accelerated push towards AI-driven data collection, all occurring within a regulatory vacuum. This situation raises significant questions about privacy, security, and the potential for data manipulation.

The current unregulated use of AI and synthetic data via technology, media, and telecommunications (TMT) and social media raises questions about the extent of government access to various forms of data.

This situation prompts discussions on how governments might leverage data to shape public perception of reality. This mirrors past instances where in the 1970's governments have used media and film to document significant cultural events, influencing geopolitics*10 ( reference 2024 film 'Fly me to the moon').

With the UK's investments in accessing human neural networks and body data, there are concerns about potential government utilisation of biology and neural networks involvement in geopolitical covert operations.*11

Broader impact on Digital rights

The UK's stance on encryption might set it apart from other democratic nations in terms of digital privacy policies. The interconnectivity of data systems presents a significant challenge. If all data can be intercepted and linked on a single framework, it becomes theoretically possible to alter or erase past and current documents, including emails, web chats, WhatsApp conversations, iPhone notes, and social media posts using AI technology. This capability underscores the critical need for robust regulation of data-driven tech companies. Such regulations should address potential interference in foreign governments, elections, and the risk of inadvertently supporting authoritarian regimes.

Conclusion

The half-term bought a significant shift in the digital landscape alongside education, entertaining experiences to thought-provoking television and news content. The enrichment coincided with Apple's removal of its Advanced Data Protection (ADP) tool for UK users following far reaching government implications. While the excitement for film, media content and technological advancements remains, there is a palpable shift in user behaviour and trust. The passion for creating content using devices like iPhones is now overshadowed by concerns about data privacy and security in our increasingly digital world.

As we move forward into the Spring term, the balance between technological advancement and personal privacy emerges as a crucial issue requiring ongoing attention, discussion, and action from both policymakers and the public. The erosion of trust in digital platforms highlights the urgent need for transparent, ethical guidelines governing the use of AI and data collection for covert use by government, commercial and private entities.

It is imperative to foster a balanced approach that safeguards individual privacy while addressing legitimate national security concerns in the age of AI and utilisation of data in covert operations. Our digital interactions and the integrity of our personal data hang in the balance, demanding vigilance and informed engagement from all online contributors and stake holders in society.

Appendix

1. https://www.wbstudiotour.co.uk/

2. https://www.natgeotv.com/me/cosmos-a-spacetime-odyssey

3. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt26227818/

4. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cgj54eq4vejo

5. https://news.sky.com/story/apple-removes-advanced-security-tool-over-uk-government-row-13314003.

6. https://bills.parliament.uk/publications/49135/documents/2650 ( point 4 first page)

7. https://www.globalencryption.org/2022/11/70-organizations-cyber-security-experts-and-elected-officials-sign-open-letter-expressing-dangers-of-the-uks-online-safety-bill/

8. https://www.standard.co.uk/news/tech/what-does-apple-axing-encryption-tool-mean-uk-users-data-safety-b1212579.html

9. https://www.libertyhumanrights.org.uk/issue/legal-challenge-investigatory-powers-act/

10. https://www.imdb.com/news/ni64525844/

11. Reference Section 'Quantum Computers and AI' https://www.the-cword.com/post/charting-the-gig-economy-the-impact-of-agi-on-uk-investment-and-sectoral-growth